In the last 6 years the gender situation has somewhat improved since the previous study: of the 24 recent Issues, 4 have 50% or more of women authors (vs. 2 issues out of the 33). As the table below shows, female authors still only amount to 30%.
It doesn't seem to be noticeably more difficult for a sole female author to publish a main article than a remark or a squib (27% vs. 22% in general), but the presence of a co-author clearly improves her chances (22% vs. 39%; in this context female co-authors of main articles are doing better than female co-authors of remarks and squibs: co-authored main articles have 48% of women authors, while in general only 39% of authors of co-authored papers are female.
To check the apparent effect of coauthorship, I compared the numbers of female and male authors in co-authored articles, whose authors had the same gender (i.e., all female or all male). There were 22 such articles, 5 all-female and 17 all-male (i.e., 23% female articles), with 11 female authors and 37 male authors (i.e., 23% female authors). This strongly suggests gender discrimination, and as a result of these data LI has decided to pass to double-blind reviewing in summer 2012.
Compare these ratios to overall results for Women in Linguistics
issue: |
single author |
co-authored |
publications overall |
37.1: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
2/3 0/5 2/8 |
1/2+1/3 1/2 3/7 |
4/8 1/7 5/15 |
37.2: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
1/1+1/1+0/1 0/1+1/1+0/1 0/1+0/1+0/1+0/1+0/1 3/11 |
2/3 1/3 0/5 3/11 |
|
37.3: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1 1/1+1/1 1/1+0/1 3/5 |
1/2 1/2 0/2 2/4 |
1/3 3/4 1/4 5/9 |
37.4: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1 0/1+0/1+0/1 1/1+0/1+0/1 1/7 |
0/2 0/2 0/4 |
0/1 0/5 1/5 1/11 |
38.1: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
1/1+0/1 0/1 1/1+0/1 2/5 |
1/3 1/2 2/5 |
2/5 0/1 2/4 4/10 |
38.2: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1 0/1+1/1 0/1+0/1+0/1+0/1 1/7 |
2/2 1/2 0/2+1/2 4/8 |
2/3 2/4 1/8 5/15 |
38.3: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+0/1 0/1+0/1+0/1+0/1+0/1+0/1 0/8 |
1/2 0/2 1/4 |
1/3 0/2 0/5 1/12 |
38.4: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+0/1 0/1 1/1+1/1+1/1 3/6 |
0/2+1/2 1/4 |
1/6 0/1 3/3 4/10 |
39.1: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
1/1 0/1+0/1+0/1+0/1 1/1+0/1+1/1 3/8 |
0/2 0/2 |
1/3 0/4 2/3 3/10 |
39.2: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1 1/1+1/1+0/1+0/1 0/1+0/1+1/1 3/8 |
1/3 1/3 |
1/4 2/4 1/3 4/11 |
39.3: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
1/1 1/1 |
2/4+0/2 1/2 1/3 4/9 |
3/7 1/2 1/3 5/10 |
39.4: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1 0/1 |
2/2+1/2 3/4 |
3/5 3/5 |
40.1: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+0/1 1/1 1/1 2/4 |
2/2+1/2 0/2 1/2+1/2 5/10 |
3/6 1/3 3/5 7/14 |
40.2: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
1/1+0/1 0/1+0/1 0/1+0/1 1/6 |
0/3 2/11 2/14(0/3) |
1/2 0/5 2/13 3/20(1/9) |
40.3: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1 0/1 0/1+0/1 0/4 |
1/2 2/4+1?/2 1/2 5?/10 |
1/3 3?/7 1/3 5?/14 |
40.4: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+0/1 0/2 |
1/2 1/2 |
1/4 1/4 |
41.1: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
1/1+0/1+0/1 0/1 0/1+0/1+1/1 2/7 |
0/3 0/3 |
1/3 0/4 1/3 2/10 |
41.2: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+0/1 0/1+0/1 0/1+0/1+0/1 0/7 |
1/2+2/3 3/5 |
3/7 0/2 0/3 3/12 |
41.3: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+0/1+1/1 0/1 0/1+0/1+0/1 1/7 |
1/2 1/2 |
2/5 0/1 0/3 2/9 |
41.4: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+0/1+1/1+0/1 0/1+0/1 1/6 |
0/2 1/2+0/3+3/3 4/10 |
1/4 0/2 4/10 5/16 |
42.1: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+0/1+0/1 0/1 0/1+0/1+0/1+0/1 0/8 |
2/3+1/2 3/5 |
0/3 0/1 3/9 3/13 |
42.2: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
1/1+0/1 0/1+0/1 1/4 |
0/2+1/2 1/2 2/6 |
2/6 1/4 3/10 |
42.3: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+0/1+0/1 0/1+0/1 0/1 0/6 |
0/2 0/2 |
0/3 0/4 0/1 0/8 |
42.4: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+0/1 0/1+0/1 0/4 |
1/2+2/2 1/2 4/6 |
3/6 1/2 0/2 4/10 |
43.1: main articles remarks and replies squibs and discussion Total |
0/1+1/1 0/1 1/3 |
0/2+1/4+1/2 0/2 2/10 |
1/2 2/8 0/3 3/13 |
main total |
13/48 = 27% 31/140 = 22% |
27/56 = 48% 51/131 = 39% |
36/96 = 38% 82/271 = 30% |